Ask Caleffi
Ask Caleffi
#4 What do your Mom and a hydronic system have in common?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Episode 4 focuses on the importance of having magnetic technology built into dirt separators. Highly efficient "dirt" removal, including both non-ferrous and ferrous (magnetic), is critical to protect today's high-efficiency heat exchangers and circulators. Caleffi is the North American market leader in magnetic dirt removal technology.
Want to hear YOUR QUESTION on Ask Caleffi, take this quick 4 question survey for your chance to hear your question in a future episode.
00:01
[Music]
00:04
welcome to ask Caleffi
00:06
the podcast that dives into real life
00:08
problems that plumbing and hvac
00:10
technicians face in the field
00:12
we're your hosts from the caleffi tech
00:14
support team i'm greg tubbs
00:16
and i'm dan firkus welcome we look
00:18
forward to sharing some stories from our
00:20
tech
00:20
calls and using our background and
00:22
expertise to make your days a little
00:24
easier
00:26
[Music]
00:29
hey there welcome back we're going to
00:31
continue on the train
00:33
of separation yeah we're going to keep
00:36
it separated
00:37
that's right so this week we're talking
00:39
dirt separators
00:40
yeah dirt and magnetic awesome so
00:44
what is it what does it do how does it
00:46
work we're gonna dive into that
00:48
right now yeah we are you know what
00:50
you're gonna see is
00:51
that in a way it's pretty similar to
00:53
that air separator we talked about last
00:55
week
00:55
that's right basically we're taking a
00:58
air separator and
00:59
turning it upside down you're no longer
01:01
venting air or
01:02
separating air right we're trying to
01:04
pull other things out of fluid
01:06
right exactly so you know you're going
01:08
to take that same
01:10
similar i won't say same i'll say
01:12
similar
01:13
large-bodied multi-pass device turning
01:16
it upside down
01:16
having the coalescing mesh in inside
01:20
and as a multi-pass device it's going to
01:23
knock the dirt and debris from the water
01:26
as it passes through it
01:27
that's right yeah so it's got a very
01:30
small pressure drop
01:31
across the vessel right that's because
01:33
of that large body
01:34
right it's very negligible it was a lot
01:37
like that air separator last week with
01:38
the large body your velocity drop
01:41
so essentially there's low to no
01:43
pressure drop right and
01:44
we do list cvs in our literature but
01:47
honestly
01:48
pretty much could ignore it in your head
01:49
loss calculations there's guys that
01:51
won't though they always want
01:52
every little detail and you can do that
01:55
you can do that but i think you know you
01:57
do that enough times you're going to
01:58
find that it's so negligible that
02:00
you'll probably stop doing it right and
02:03
we got to remember every time we're
02:04
talking
02:05
a separator of any kind it is a
02:07
multi-pass device right
02:09
is that similar to a y strainer greg not
02:11
at all
02:12
we we definitely know that y strainers
02:14
are more restrictive
02:16
and those are typically a one passed
02:18
filter type device
02:19
right right and those those you will
02:22
tend to get more of a pressure drop
02:23
through as they start to collect dirt
02:25
and debris because
02:25
they don't have that large body right
02:27
they'll plug up where
02:29
a separator unless the system is really
02:31
dirty separator
02:32
should not plug up no not if you're
02:34
doing your maintenance properly
02:36
right yeah i mean you're gonna find that
02:38
you know if you're working with a dirty
02:40
system and you install a
02:41
dirt or magnetic separator
02:44
it's not gonna may not be an annual
02:46
maintenance thing to start with you
02:48
might be back once a once a day once a
02:50
week
02:51
maybe down to once a month and then
02:52
hopefully working it out to where you're
02:54
you're out there doing annual
02:56
maintenance and and doing a flush on
02:57
them
02:58
absolutely but we always recommend if
03:01
you know for a fact that the system is
03:02
very dirty to begin
03:04
with before you install one of these we
03:06
would always recommend that you do a
03:07
power flush on the system
03:09
flush and clean flush and clean and then
03:11
install this and then do your water
03:13
testing and then add inhibitors as
03:15
needed
03:16
right right absolutely then you can use
03:18
this to just
03:19
finish cleaning up the system and then
03:21
maintain it
03:22
sure but say you know a contractor
03:25
didn't do all that
03:26
can these be taken apart to clean out if
03:28
they're that bad they can
03:30
i mean you're gonna find that you're
03:32
coming in and doing the annual
03:33
maintenance and we're going to talk more
03:34
about that as we
03:35
as we get into this they're pretty easy
03:38
to clean out but
03:39
they are you can disassemble them and
03:41
pull the pull the coalescing mesh out at
03:43
least in smaller brass models and clean
03:45
that
03:46
yeah and obviously our steel ones we
03:48
can't do that because that's an all
03:49
welded body
03:50
right they don't have removable heads on
03:52
those unlike some other manufacturers
03:55
typically if it's that bad though i mean
03:58
again we would say hey
03:59
probably not a bad idea to power flush
04:01
the system right yeah do a flush and
04:03
clean
04:04
yep you talk about the different sizes
04:06
you know like the separators we talked
04:07
about last week you know we have our
04:09
smaller brass models anywhere from
04:12
you know three-quarter up to two inch
04:15
um and then steel models from two inch
04:17
all the way up to
04:19
14 inch yeah that's a big separator
04:22
huge body and all those models come
04:25
magnetic or non-magnetic
04:26
right right yeah they do with the
04:28
magnetic models i mean
04:30
the smaller brass ones will be a clip-on
04:32
magnet the larger steel ones will be
04:35
you know and insert it magnet into an
04:37
insert inserted into a well
04:39
that's right and we're going to go back
04:41
and kind of
04:42
beat this little subject in the head
04:44
again these are not for potable water
04:46
absolutely not nope not for potable at
04:49
all we get that question
04:51
quite a bit too about removing scale and
04:54
debris from potable water systems and
04:57
you know no they're not low lead they're
04:59
designed for
05:00
a closed-loop hydronic system hydronic
05:03
or chilled water
05:04
hydronic or chilled water only closed
05:06
loop
05:07
and potable water systems
05:10
you know they're not multi-pass systems
05:14
you know if you're looking to get rid of
05:15
debris out of a potable water system
05:17
we're always going to tell you look at a
05:20
filter
05:20
absolutely yeah that that's absolutely
05:23
the way to go
05:24
so we talk about magnetic separators
05:26
greg you know did you realize who the
05:28
first
05:29
one in north america was to introduce
05:32
magnetic separation
05:33
well from what i understand it's calefi
05:36
it's us it is us
05:38
yep so a lot of manufacturers out there
05:39
were the first ones to bring that to the
05:41
north america market
05:43
yeah i mean many manufacturers don't do
05:45
both
05:46
no no they don't so how do these things
05:49
work
05:50
well they work pretty similar to that
05:51
air separator they reduce the velocity
05:53
they slow down the fluid
05:55
passing through the coalescing mesh
05:57
which allows that that mesh to knock the
05:59
dirt and debris loose
06:01
that dirt and debris will fall down into
06:03
the bottom of
06:05
the separator the magnetic portion when
06:08
you have the magnetic separation that'll
06:10
pull out very fine
06:12
magnetite right and then the mesh in
06:14
these
06:15
so when we're talking our smaller brass
06:17
ones those are glass reinforced nylon
06:20
and then when we step to the commercial
06:21
steel units
06:23
those have the stainless steel yeah yeah
06:26
they do
06:27
and those will have a larger ball valve
06:29
on the bottom for cleaning
06:30
so i mean we do have a discharge port on
06:32
on the bottom of all of our separators
06:35
for cleaning and
06:36
you know that's something that when
06:37
you're out doing you'll typically shut a
06:39
pump off
06:40
to you know drop the pressure in the
06:42
system or and then do a downward flush
06:44
on
06:45
sure right after you remove the magnet
06:47
and none of our magnets are a wetted
06:49
magnet
06:50
these uh the larger commercial ones are
06:52
a bayonet that goes into the bottom of
06:54
the
06:54
of the body the smaller brass ones are
06:58
like you said before they're a magnetic
07:01
band that goes around you would pull
07:03
that off and then do the flush
07:04
yeah that'll clip right onto the body
07:07
what's interesting is our larger
07:09
separators you know will actually have
07:12
up to three
07:12
magnets inserted into the bottom yes
07:15
that's a lot of a lot of grabbing power
07:17
certainly is so what about installing
07:20
these things
07:21
i mean you have any tips for for the
07:23
guys out there yeah i always like to put
07:25
them on the return side of the system
07:27
you know if i can put them in right
07:28
before the boiler
07:29
and i know i'm protecting the boiler
07:31
heat exchanger you know
07:32
again you want to make sure that you're
07:34
going to be in line
07:36
piped in line so that you get that good
07:38
velocity drop as that water passes
07:40
through it
07:41
absolutely and that's protecting the
07:43
boiler you know
07:44
catching the majority of the debris on
07:46
the first couple passes
07:48
and keeping it out of those smaller
07:50
passageways and some of these
07:52
you know very restrictive heat
07:54
exchangers right there
07:55
yeah absolutely you know you look at
07:57
that magnetite that's almost like a
07:58
black sludge or tar
08:00
in the system sand yeah by almost like a
08:02
sand right
08:04
and it's awful on uh variable speed
08:06
pumps
08:07
yeah that's kind of where my mind was
08:09
going you talk about the variable speed
08:11
pumps and the variable speed drives have
08:13
little magnets
08:14
within the drive so if you don't have
08:16
some type of magnetic separation in your
08:18
system
08:19
that pump will do that so that pump's
08:21
going to suck that magnetite in so you
08:23
if you have uh
08:24
you know if you find you're going out to
08:26
a system and you're replacing these
08:28
variable speed drives
08:30
and you're consistently having to do
08:32
that and you don't
08:33
you don't have magnetic separation that
08:36
most likely that
08:37
there you have a lot of magnetite in the
08:38
system that's getting drawn into that
08:41
to the magnets of that pump causing
08:42
premature failures
08:44
right it'll lock it tight yeah
08:46
absolutely i think
08:47
almost any variable speed pump
08:49
manufacturer out there will recommend
08:51
that you have the magnetic separation to
08:53
protect the pumps
08:54
right well how about flow direction we
08:57
get that question an awful lot about
08:58
just about everything we sell and
09:01
honestly
09:02
it doesn't know the difference right
09:03
it's an open barrel inside
09:05
right absolutely with being an open
09:07
barrel it's passed through so it doesn't
09:09
matter what direction the flow is going
09:11
that coalescing mesh is going to
09:12
separate that
09:14
the dirt debris and magnetite is going
09:16
to be drawn down to the bottom
09:17
your gravity is what's pulling that down
09:19
and the fact that the velocity drops
09:22
so much within that body it allows the
09:26
those particles to fall to the bottom
09:28
right
09:29
the only thing the only product i think
09:31
that we have that it does really making
09:34
a
09:34
have an effect on is that that rotating
09:37
collar model
09:38
that na 5465 right that one with the
09:42
poly
09:43
body that one has an in and out it does
09:46
and well that's a vertical device it's a
09:49
vertical but it can
09:50
be turned as it'll be horizontal
09:51
horizontal too if you've got a really
09:52
small
09:53
system yeah thing to remember with those
09:55
like the vertical air separators we
09:57
talked about last week
09:58
lower flow capacities only up to about
10:00
10 gallons per minute
10:02
sure sure so and again that's because
10:05
that one is not a direct
10:07
um a direct pass-through device
10:10
sure so from installation
10:14
to now maintenance i mean we walk people
10:17
through a maintenance procedure all the
10:19
time on these don't we
10:20
we do the key to anything is going to be
10:22
maintenance so you want to make sure
10:24
that you get the system cleaned up
10:25
and then you're able to put it on a
10:27
maintenance cycle sure
10:29
typically when when a guy wants to know
10:31
how to blow one of these off
10:33
we're gonna tell them hey man you gotta
10:35
turn off the pumps
10:36
make sure the system is just sitting at
10:37
rest you know make sure all the
10:39
this is gonna make sure all the magnetic
10:41
material doesn't go back into the system
10:44
when you pull the magnets
10:45
because a little suction from the pump
10:46
can pull up the finer debris yeah it can
10:49
well especially once you pull that
10:50
magnet out and you release that
10:52
yep pull the magnet and then you're able
10:55
to
10:56
open that drain valve yeah you open that
10:58
drain valve you do a downward flush
11:00
and generally recommend continuing to
11:03
let it flush
11:04
for about 10 to 20 seconds after you see
11:06
clear fluid coming out
11:08
and you know you have that purged out
11:10
sure then you can close up the valve and
11:12
and fire up the pumps again right put it
11:14
back in service
11:16
certainly so i got another question for
11:18
you greg there
11:19
you know most of our air sorry our dirt
11:22
separators
11:23
have either a plug in the top or a stem
11:26
with a cap off the top
11:27
what's the purpose of that that's a
11:29
great question
11:30
i've seen plenty of contractors will
11:33
actually add an additional
11:34
air vent on them right because they have
11:37
the the coalescing mesh in there yes
11:39
it's removing
11:40
dirt but it will also catch any
11:44
air bubbles coming in so it's like a
11:46
secondary air removal
11:47
right nice yeah the smaller brass ones
11:49
have a half inch
11:51
female mpt connection where you can put
11:53
one of our
11:54
our mini keller valcal you know half
11:56
inch right air vents on top
11:59
and you know you get a little bit a
12:00
little bit of additional air separation
12:02
certainly can and then those larger
12:04
commercial units those have a
12:06
three-quarter
12:06
piece of stand pipe off the top that's
12:08
threaded and
12:10
that big 502 air vent max cal
12:13
yep the 501 502 max cal i've seen people
12:16
put that pink
12:17
that thing on there as a secondary i
12:19
don't think you can ever have
12:20
enough air vents in this system no it
12:22
know properly
12:24
yep i agree you know you're going to
12:25
have an air separator on the
12:27
the supply side you're going to have a
12:28
dirt separator on the return
12:30
side you're going to have air vents
12:31
within the system why not throw an air
12:34
vent on top of that dirt separator and
12:35
get a little bit of additional air
12:37
removal
12:38
well and i think probably the last
12:39
question we could ask here is
12:42
how often how often do we have to
12:45
purge this system i mean we get that
12:47
question a lot too
12:49
and like anything else it depends on how
12:52
dirty the system is
12:53
right yeah that's really what is going
12:55
to determine how often you clean it
12:58
i mentioned it a little earlier you may
12:59
find that you initially put it in and
13:02
you're you know you're back once a week
13:04
to purge it and then maybe
13:06
once a month and then maybe six months
13:08
and then
13:09
i mean i think the overall goal would be
13:12
to get the system cleaned up to where
13:14
you you're purging it with your annual
13:17
maintenance
13:18
exactly so it becomes part of your
13:20
annual maintenance procedure
13:21
i think that pretty well covers it you
13:23
know we asked all the questions
13:25
next week we're going to finish off
13:28
separation with
13:29
hydraulics operators awesome i'm look
13:31
i'm looking forward to that one
13:33
yeah so tune in next week we're going to
13:35
talk hydraulic separation
13:37
thanks for tuning in thank you thank you
13:40
for tuning in
13:41
if you ever need help please feel free
13:43
to contact our tech support team
13:45
anytime at techsupport.you
13:49
calefi.com or call us during our
13:52
business hours
13:53
at 7 30 am to 4 30 pm
13:56
central time at 414
14:00
238
14:07
[Music]